February 14, 2021
SHARE
CANADALAND
#359 The Convenient “Pretendian”
Michelle Latimer was the buzziest Canadian director and showrunner of 2020. But it all came crashing down in December when a CBC investigation called into question her Indigenous identity claims.
Jesse Brown
Host & Publisher
Andréa Schmidt
Managing Editor, Podcasts

Latimer’s documentary Inconvenient Indian premiered at TIFF and reaped plaudits and awards. It’s now been pulled from distribution. Her series Trickster, based on a novel by Eden Robinson, debuted on the CBC and was slated for a second season. It’s been cancelled.

Why does the Canadian cultural establishment make darlings of figures like Latimer? Ryan McMahon joins Jesse to discuss.

Then documentary filmmaker Alethea Arnaquq-Baril, who is featured in Inconvenient Indian, considers the ethics and responsibility of storytelling, and why this controversy has been hurtful to so many Indigenous people.

And Steven Lonsdale, whose seal hunt Latimer filmed for Inconvenient Indian, explains what he’d like to see done with that footage.

Correction: In this episode, Jesse says that author Eden Robinson has promised to donate all future author royalties from the Trickster books to the Haisla Language Authority. In fact, Robinson has promised to donate future income from the Trickster TV series to the Haisla people.

Clarification: In an earlier version of this episode, Jesse said, “The CBC dug in to census records that say Latimer’s grandfather was not Indigenous or Métis, as [Latimer] had claimed, but French-Canadian,” a formulation that erroneously and unintentionally implied that the Métis are not Indigenous. We have amended the episode to remove this implication.

This episode is brought to you by the Rotman School of Management, Kilne, Athletic Brewing and Article.

Additional music by Audio Network.

More from this series
I woke up one morning and instantly knew something has gone terribly wrong, something's wrong with my body, and I quickly realized I'd lost all sexual sensation in my body and there was like a dulling of tactile sensation in my genital region and it's just never gone away. -Emily Grey, co-founder of the Canadian Post-SSRI Sexual Dysfunction Society
July 7, 2025
Host Sam grills Canadaland management on the company’s new A.I. guidelines
July 3, 2025
Today we are bringing you a great episode from our friends at Canada’s National Observer.
July 1, 2025
I love dancing and I loathe Crokinole. - Lucy Maude Montgomery
June 30, 2025
“ When talking about immigration, you shouldn't use the word sweep because it implies that immigrants are something undesirable to be swept away. Notably, they don't say the same thing about homeless people.” -Alex Skopic
June 26, 2025
“ What we should be aware of is that our Prime Minister just fucked us up royally at the G7. “ - Professor Amir Attaran
June 23, 2025
Are tweens going to Make Podcasting Great again?
June 19, 2025
 Jesse Brown pulls a thread on his sweater and unravels a mystery.
June 16, 2025
all podcasts arrow All Podcasts
CANADALAND